Median Income
$76,776
2% higher than US avg
Home Value
$469,100
66% higher than US avg
Violent Crime
329/100K
14% lower than US avg
Bachelor's+
50.4%
50% higher than US avg
Median Rent
$1,682
45% higher than US avg
Obesity Rate
29.3%
9% lower than US avg
Unemployment
4.1%
14% higher than US avg
Poverty Rate
6.6%
47% lower than US avg
How Butler Beach Compares to the U.S. Average (100% = U.S. avg)
People
Population4,723
Median Age61.7 yrs
Density1,859/mi²
Male / Female46% / 54%
Largest GroupWhite 95%
Veterans8.5%
Economy
A
Median Income$76,776
Per Capita$56,846
Unemployment4.1%
Poverty6.6%
County GDP$18,621M
Commute29 min
Housing
B
Home Value$469,100
Rent$1,682
Ownership85.4%
Zillow$272,175
Housing Units4,718
Rent Burden28.3%
Crime
F
Violent329/100K
Property1,957/100K
Health
Obesity29.3%
Uninsured9.1%
Smoking11.0%
Depression20.1%
Heart Disease5.0%
Climate
Avg Temp71°F (22°C)
AQI41 (Good)
Rain50.6 in/yr
Sunny Days314/yr
Elevation8 ft (2 m)
Education
A+
Bachelor's+50.4%
High School+96.0%
Graduate+14.2%
School Score7.13
Community
2024 VoteR 65% / D 34%
Commute29 min
Broadband94.0%
EV Stations1
Libraries7
Is Butler Beach a Good Place to Live?
Based on current data, Butler Beach receives an overall livability score of 3.3 out of 5.0, earning a grade of B. Key strengths include a highly educated population, abundant sunshine, a low poverty rate, high health insurance coverage. Areas to be aware of include high housing costs. Butler Beach offers a solid quality of life with a good balance of affordability, safety, and opportunity.
Economy & Jobs
The median household income in Butler Beach is $76,776, roughly in line with the national average of $75,149. Unemployment stands at 4.1%, indicating a healthy job market. Only 6.6% of residents live below the poverty line, well below the national rate of 12.4%. Workers commute an average of 29 minutes.
Cost of Living & Housing
The median home value in Butler Beach is $469,100, making it a premium housing market at 66% above the U.S. median of $281,900. Renters pay a median of $1,682 per month, significantly above the national average of $1,163. The price-to-income ratio of 6.1x means housing costs are stretched relative to local earnings.
Safety & Crime
Violent crime in Butler Beach is below the national average at 329 per 100,000 residents (U.S. avg: 380). Property crime occurs at a rate of 1,957 per 100,000, near the national average.
Education
Butler Beach is a highly educated community / 50.4% of adults hold a bachelor's degree or higher, well above the national average of 33.7%. 96.0% have completed high school. Local schools score 7.1/10 in standardized testing, reflecting strong academic performance.
Climate & Weather
Butler Beach has a warm climate with an average annual temperature of 71°F. Winters average 58°F in January while summers reach 82°F in July. With 314 sunny days per year, residents enjoy well above the national average of sunshine. Annual precipitation totals 50.6 inches. Air quality is rated Good with a median AQI of 41.
Butler Beach has a population of 4,723 with a density of 1,859 people per square mile, spread across 2.7 square miles. The median age is 61.7 years, 59% older than the national median of 38.9. The gender split is 54% female and 46% male. The city is predominantly White (94.9%), with 1.6% Hispanic. English is the primary language spoken at home by 93.6% of residents, while 6.4% speak Spanish. 8.5% of the population are veterans, above the national rate of 6.0%. 10.6% of residents have a disability. 94.4% have health insurance coverage.
Population
61.7yrs
Median Age
59% above US avg
Race & Ethnicity
Butler Beach vs U.S. Average
Language Spoken at Home
English Only
93.6%
19% above US avg
Spanish
6.4%
52% below US avg
Social Characteristics
Butler Beach vs U.S. Average
The median household income in Butler Beach is $76,776, which is 2% above the national average of $75,149. Per capita income is $56,846 (above the $39,052 national figure). The average weekly wage is $1,154, 19% lower than the U.S. average. The unemployment rate is 4.1% (above the 3.6% US average). 6.6% of residents live below the poverty line, lower than the national rate of 12.4%. The area has 11,005 business establishments, including 771 restaurants. The cost of living index is 103.4, roughly in line with the national average. Workers commute an average of 29 minutes. 25.7% of workers work from home (above the 15.2% national rate).
Income: Butler Beach vs U.S.
Income
| Median HH Income | $76,776 |
| 2% above US avg |
| Per Capita Income | $56,846 |
| Avg Weekly Wage | $1,154 |
| IRS Avg AGI | $147,374 |
| Gini Index | 0.458 (0=equal, 1=unequal) |
Employment & Poverty
| Unemployment | 4.1% |
| 14% above US avg |
| Poverty Rate | 6.6% |
| 47% below US avg |
| Establishments (County) | 11,005 |
| County GDP | $18,621M |
Business (County)
| Restaurants | 771 |
| Healthcare | 881 |
| Retail | 942 |
| Manufacturing | 123 |
Tax & Cost of Living
| Property Tax (IRS) | $8,649 |
| 147% above US avg |
| Cost of Living | 103.40 (100=avg) |
| Effective Tax Rate | 1.84% |
Commute & Transportation
| Commute Time | 28.6 min |
| Drive Alone | 67.4% |
| Public Transit | 0.0% |
| Work from Home | 25.7% |
The median home value in Butler Beach is $469,100, 66% above the national median of $281,900. Zillow estimates the typical home value at $272,175, lower than the Census estimate. Homes sell for 97.4% of their list price. Monthly rent averages $1,682 (45% above the national average of $1,163). Fair market rent ranges from $1,296 for a one-bedroom to $1,526 for a two-bedroom apartment. 85.4% of housing units are owner-occupied (above the 65.4% national rate). There are 4,718 total housing units in the city. The median year a home was built is 1987. The average annual property tax is $8,649 (higher than the $3,500 national average). 28.3% of renters spend 30% or more of their income on housing. The home price-to-income ratio is 6.1x, above the traditionally affordable threshold of 3-4x.
Home Values
| Census Median | $469,100 |
| 66% above US avg |
| Zillow ZHVI | $272,175 |
| Median List Price | $495,000 |
Real Estate Market (Redfin)
| Median List Price | $495,000 |
| $/Sq Ft | $338 |
| Homes Sold | 11 |
| Sale-to-List Ratio | 97.4% |
| Price Drops | 18.8% |
| Inventory | 96 |
Rental Costs
| Census Median Rent | $1,682 |
| 45% above US avg |
| Rent Burden | 28.3% |
HUD Fair Market Rent
| Studio | $1,212 |
| 1 Bedroom | $1,296 |
| 2 Bedrooms | $1,526 |
| 3 Bedrooms | $1,971 |
| 4 Bedrooms | $2,261 |
Ownership & Property
| Homeownership | 85.4% |
| Owner-Occupied | 85.4% |
| Renter-Occupied | 14.6% |
| Housing Units | 4,718 |
| Median Year Built | 1987 |
Property Tax
| Avg Tax (IRS) | $8,649 |
| 147% above US avg |
| Effective Rate | 1.84% |
In Butler Beach, 29.3% of adults are obese, below the national rate of 32.1%. 7.9% have diabetes (below the 10.5% national rate). Heart disease affects 5.0% of residents. 28.5% have high blood pressure. 11.0% are current smokers (below the 14.0% national rate). 19.1% report binge drinking. 16.9% are physically inactive, below the national average. 20.1% report depression. 16.9% experience frequent mental distress. 9.1% of residents lack health insurance. The primary care physician ratio is 1:1,052. The dentist ratio is 1:2,019. 91.3% of residents have access to exercise opportunities. The food environment index is 8.8 out of 10.
Health Metrics: Butler Beach vs U.S. Average (%)
Chronic Conditions
| Obesity | 29.3% |
| 9% below US avg |
| Diabetes | 7.9% |
| Heart Disease | 5.0% |
| High Blood Pressure | 28.5% |
| Asthma | 9.8% |
| COPD | 5.3% |
| Cancer | 8.3% |
| Stroke | 2.4% |
Behaviors & Mental Health
| Smoking | 11.0% |
| 21% below US avg |
| Binge Drinking | 19.1% |
| Physical Inactivity | 16.9% |
| Depression | 20.1% |
| Mental Distress | 16.9% |
| Physical Distress | 11.6% |
| Short Sleep | 32.3% |
Healthcare Access
| Insurance Rate | 94.4% |
| Uninsured | 9.1% |
| 6% above US avg |
| Primary Care | 1:1,052 |
| Dentists | 1:2,019 |
| Mental Health | 1:681 |
| Checkup Rate | 77.0% |
| Dental Visits | 66.2% |
| Premature Death | 5,815/100K |
Food & Exercise
| Food Environment | 8.8/10 |
| Exercise Access | 91.3% |
| Healthcare Facilities | 881 |
Butler Beach has a violent crime rate of 329 per 100,000 residents, 14% below the national average of 380. Property crime stands at 1,957 per 100,000, 0% below the U.S. average. The county recorded 33 fatal traffic crashes. Overall, Butler Beach receives a safety grade of F.
Crime Rates: Butler Beach vs U.S. Average (per 100,000)
Violent Crime
| Total Violent | 328.7/100K |
| 14% below US avg |
| |
Property Crime
| Total Property | 1,957.3/100K |
| 0% below US avg |
Traffic Safety
| Fatal Crashes (County/yr) | 33 |
| Avg Accident Severity | 0.0 / 4.0 |
Safety Score
| Safety Grade | F |
| Safety Score | 1.0 / 5.0 |
Butler Beach has a warm climate with an average annual temperature of 71°F (22°C). Winters average 58°F in January while summers reach 82°F in July. The area gets 314 sunny days per year, well above the U.S. average of 205 / making it one of the sunnier locations in the country. Annual precipitation totals 50.6 inches (wetter than the 38-inch national average). Air quality is rated Good with a median AQI of 41. The city sits at an elevation of 8 feet, near sea level.
Temperature
58°F Jan (14°C)
82°F Jul (28°C)
| Annual Average | 71.2°F |
| 32% above US avg |
| January Average | 58°F (14°C) |
| July Average | 82°F (28°C) |
| Sunny Days | 314 days/yr |
Geography
| Elevation | 8 ft (2 m) |
| Area | 2.7 sq mi (6.9 km²) |
| Population Density | 1,859/sq mi |
| Coordinates | 29.7989°N, 81.2648°W |
| Timezone | America/New_York |
| County | St. Johns County County |
| Nearest Airport | Northeast Florida Regional (UST)
12 miles away |
Precipitation & Snow
Annual Rainfall
50.6"
33% above US avg
Wettest Month (Aug)
6.46"
Air Quality
| AQI Median | 41.0 |
| Rating | Good |
Natural Hazard Risk
| Overall Risk | Relatively Moderate |
| Risk Score | 87.5 / 100 |
| Social Vulnerability | 11.4 / 100 |
| Community Resilience | 96.3 / 100 |
Hazard Breakdown
| Tornado |
Relatively Moderate |
| Hurricane |
Relatively High |
| Earthquake |
Very Low |
| Wildfire |
Relatively Moderate |
| Flood |
Relatively Moderate |
| Hail |
Very Low |
| Strong Wind |
Relatively Low |
| Heat Wave |
Relatively Moderate |
| Winter Weather |
No Rating |
| Lightning |
Relatively High |
| Drought |
Relatively Low |
| Cold Wave |
Very Low |
| Landslide |
Very Low |
| Coastal Flood |
Relatively High |
Source: FEMA National Risk Index v1.20 (Dec 2025)
Hurricane History
25 hurricanes (Cat 1+) within 500 km since 1980.
Strongest: Category 4. Most recent: Helene (2024, Cat 4).
| Year |
Name |
Category |
Closest |
| 2024 |
Helene |
Category 4 |
235 km |
| 2024 |
Milton |
Category 3 |
158 km |
| 2024 |
Debby |
Category 1 |
206 km |
| 2023 |
Idalia |
Category 4 |
192 km |
| 2022 |
Ian |
Category 3 |
151 km |
| 2022 |
Nicole |
Category 1 |
262 km |
| 2020 |
Isaias |
Category 1 |
216 km |
| 2019 |
Dorian |
Category 3 |
151 km |
| 2017 |
Irma |
Category 1 |
200 km |
| 2016 |
Matthew |
Category 4 |
56 km |
| 2016 |
Hermine |
Category 1 |
269 km |
| 2014 |
Arthur |
Category 1 |
202 km |
| 2005 |
Ophelia |
Category 1 |
233 km |
| 2004 |
Jeanne |
Category 3 |
212 km |
| 2004 |
Frances |
Category 2 |
245 km |
| 2004 |
Charley |
Category 1 |
56 km |
| 1999 |
Floyd |
Category 3 |
209 km |
| 1999 |
Dennis |
Category 2 |
272 km |
| 1999 |
Irene |
Category 1 |
141 km |
| 1996 |
Bertha |
Category 2 |
292 km |
Source: NOAA IBTrACS (Cat 1+, 1980–2026)
Tornado History
384 tornadoes (EF0+) within 100 km since 1950.
Strongest: EF3. Total: 17 fatalities, 181 injuries.
| Date |
Rating |
Distance |
Fatalities |
| Feb 2, 2007 |
EF3 |
99 km |
13 |
| Nov 1, 1997 |
EF3 |
93 km |
0 |
| Feb 7, 1971 |
EF3 |
30 km |
0 |
| Apr 15, 1958 |
EF3 |
9 km |
0 |
| Oct 12, 2023 |
EF2 |
26 km |
0 |
| Aug 18, 2020 |
EF2 |
85 km |
0 |
| Sep 10, 2017 |
EF2 |
9 km |
0 |
| Dec 25, 2006 |
EF2 |
86 km |
0 |
| Dec 25, 2006 |
EF2 |
72 km |
0 |
| Aug 12, 2004 |
EF2 |
91 km |
0 |
| Mar 29, 2001 |
EF2 |
48 km |
0 |
| Feb 22, 1998 |
EF2 |
72 km |
1 |
| Oct 7, 1996 |
EF2 |
99 km |
0 |
| Feb 2, 1996 |
EF2 |
73 km |
0 |
| Apr 24, 1995 |
EF2 |
48 km |
0 |
| Feb 27, 1984 |
EF2 |
73 km |
0 |
| Nov 20, 1983 |
EF2 |
61 km |
0 |
| Nov 20, 1983 |
EF2 |
39 km |
0 |
| Sep 3, 1979 |
EF2 |
71 km |
0 |
| Sep 3, 1979 |
EF2 |
79 km |
0 |
Source: NOAA SPC (EF0+, 1950–2024)
Wildfire History
20 wildfires (100+ acres) within 100 km.
Largest: UNNAMED (121,213 ac, 1998).
| Year |
Name |
Acres |
Distance |
| 1998 |
UNNAMED |
121,213 |
68 km |
| 1998 |
UNNAMED |
24,956 |
23 km |
| 1985 |
UNNAMED |
19,129 |
65 km |
| 2007 |
UNNAMED |
13,806 |
83 km |
| 2006 |
JUNIPER |
11,998 |
76 km |
| 1998 |
UNNAMED |
9,972 |
97 km |
| 1985 |
UNNAMED |
9,807 |
31 km |
| 1998 |
UNNAMED |
9,705 |
74 km |
| 1985 |
UNNAMED |
9,554 |
42 km |
| 1985 |
UNNAMED |
8,382 |
94 km |
| 2009 |
JUNIPER SPRINGS |
8,363 |
76 km |
| 1998 |
UNNAMED |
7,345 |
9 km |
| 1998 |
UNNAMED |
7,078 |
93 km |
| 2011 |
SANTE FE |
6,497 |
80 km |
| 2007 |
UNNAMED |
6,345 |
56 km |
| 2011 |
ESPANOLA FIRE |
5,468 |
32 km |
| 2012 |
UNNAMED |
5,431 |
93 km |
| 1991 |
UNNAMED |
4,948 |
37 km |
| 1998 |
UNNAMED |
4,907 |
81 km |
| 2010 |
UNNAMED |
4,864 |
67 km |
Source: NIFC/IRWIN (100+ acres)
Monthly Weather
| Month |
Avg Temperature |
Precipitation |
Summary |
| January |
58°F (14°C) |
3.0 in |
Coldest |
| February |
58°F (14°C) |
3.5 in |
|
| March |
63°F (17°C) |
3.7 in |
|
| April |
68°F (20°C) |
2.4 in |
Driest |
| May |
74°F (23°C) |
3.4 in |
|
| June |
79°F (26°C) |
5.9 in |
|
| July |
82°F (28°C) |
5.9 in |
Warmest |
| August |
81°F (27°C) |
6.5 in |
Wettest |
| September |
79°F (26°C) |
6.4 in |
|
| October |
72°F (22°C) |
3.5 in |
|
| November |
65°F (18°C) |
2.4 in |
|
| December |
59°F (15°C) |
2.8 in |
|
Butler Beach has a seasonal temperature swing of 25°F / from 58°F in January to 82°F in July. Total annual precipitation is 49.4 inches, with August being the wettest month (6.5") and April the driest (2.4").
Average costs for common services in Butler Beach. Prices are estimated based on regional cost of living data and may vary by provider.
Healthcare
| Doctor Visit (Primary Care) |
$259 ($155–$414) |
| Specialist Visit |
$362 ($207–$569) |
| Urgent Care Visit |
$207 ($103–$362) |
| Emergency Room Visit |
$2,275 ($827–$5,170) |
| Dental Cleaning |
$134 ($78–$207) |
| Dental Filling |
$259 ($155–$414) |
View all 40 services
Auto Repair
| Oil Change (Conventional) |
$47 ($26–$78) |
| Oil Change (Synthetic) |
$78 ($52–$124) |
| Brake Pad Replacement |
$310 ($155–$517) |
| Tire Rotation |
$41 ($21–$78) |
| New Tires (Set of 4) |
$620 ($414–$1,034) |
| Battery Replacement |
$207 ($103–$362) |
View all 18 services
Home Services
| Plumber (Per Hour) |
$103 ($62–$155) |
| Electrician (Per Hour) |
$93 ($52–$145) |
| HVAC Repair |
$414 ($155–$827) |
| HVAC System Install |
$7,238 ($4,136–$12,408) |
| Roof Repair |
$1,034 ($414–$2,068) |
| Roof Replacement |
$9,306 ($5,687–$15,510) |
View all 25 services
Legal
| Divorce (Uncontested) |
$1,551 ($517–$3,619) |
| Divorce (Contested) |
$15,510 ($5,170–$31,020) |
| DUI Defense |
$5,170 ($2,068–$10,340) |
| Bankruptcy (Chapter 7) |
$1,551 ($827–$3,102) |
| Will Preparation |
$517 ($207–$1,034) |
| Trust Preparation |
$2,585 ($1,034–$5,170) |
View all 12 services
Personal Care
| Men's Haircut |
$26 ($16–$47) |
| Women's Haircut |
$57 ($31–$103) |
| Hair Coloring (Full) |
$155 ($78–$259) |
| Manicure |
$26 ($16–$47) |
| Pedicure |
$41 ($26–$67) |
| Massage (1 Hour) |
$83 ($52–$134) |
View all 12 services
Food & Grocery
| Gallon of Milk (per gallon) |
$4.24 ($3.10–$5.69) |
| Dozen Eggs (per dozen) |
$3.62 ($2.59–$5.17) |
| Loaf of Bread |
$3.93 ($2.59–$5.69) |
| Chicken Breast (per lb) |
$4.65 ($3.10–$6.72) |
| Ground Beef (per lb) |
$5.69 ($4.14–$7.76) |
| Rice (per lb) |
$1.03 ($0.62–$1.86) |
View all 20 services
Utilities
| Electricity (Monthly) |
$145 ($83–$259) |
| Natural Gas (Monthly) |
$72 ($31–$155) |
| Water/Sewer (Monthly) |
$72 ($41–$124) |
| Internet (Monthly) |
$72 ($41–$103) |
| Cell Phone Plan (Monthly) |
$67 ($31–$103) |
| Cable TV (Monthly) |
$88 ($52–$155) |
View all 8 services
Transportation
| Monthly Parking (Downtown) |
$207 ($78–$517) |
| Car Insurance (Annual) |
$2,068 ($1,241–$3,619) |
| Bus Pass (Monthly) |
$72 ($31–$134) |
| Taxi/Uber (5-Mile Ride) |
$16 ($8.27–$26) |
| Car Registration (Annual) |
$103 ($31–$259) |
| Driver's License Renewal |
$31 ($16–$78) |
View all 8 services
Education & Childcare
| Daycare (Infant, Monthly) |
$1,241 ($620–$2,585) |
| Daycare (Toddler, Monthly) |
$1,034 ($517–$2,068) |
| After-School Care (Monthly) |
$414 ($207–$724) |
| Tutoring (Per Hour) |
$52 ($26–$103) |
| SAT/ACT Prep Course |
$1,034 ($414–$2,585) |
| Private School (K-12, Annual) |
$12,925 ($5,170–$31,020) |
View all 8 services
Pets
| Vet Visit (Routine Checkup) |
$62 ($31–$103) |
| Dog Vaccination (Annual) |
$103 ($52–$207) |
| Dog Grooming |
$62 ($31–$103) |
| Pet Boarding (Per Night) |
$41 ($21–$78) |
| Dog Spay/Neuter |
$310 ($155–$517) |
| Cat Spay/Neuter |
$207 ($103–$414) |
View all 9 services
Childcare
| Center-Based (monthly) |
| Infant | $1,212 |
| Toddler | $1,061 |
| Preschool | $1,018 |
| Family Childcare (monthly) |
| Infant | $650 |
| Toddler | $541 |
| Preschool | $541 |
Source: DOL Women's Bureau (2022)
Frequently Asked Questions About Butler Beach
What is the population of Butler Beach?
Butler Beach has a population of 4,723 residents and is located in Florida. The population density is 1,859 people per square mile, spread across 2.7 square miles. The median age of residents is 61.7 years, which is older than the national median of 38.9 years. The population is 54% female and 46% male.
Is Butler Beach expensive to live in?
Butler Beach has a cost of living roughly in line with the national average, with an index of 103.4 (baseline: 100). The median household income is $76,776, 2% above the national average of $75,149. The median home value is $469,100 (66% above the U.S. median). Renters pay a median of $1,682 per month, above the national average of $1,163. The home price-to-income ratio is 6.1x, which means housing is a stretch relative to local earnings.
Is Butler Beach safe?
Butler Beach is safer than the national average, with a violent crime rate of 329 per 100,000 compared to the U.S. rate of 380. Property crime occurs at a rate of 1,957 per 100,000 (below the national average). Overall, Butler Beach receives a safety grade of F based on combined crime data.
What is the weather like in Butler Beach?
Butler Beach has a warm climate with an average annual temperature of 71°F (22°C). Winter temperatures average 58°F in January, while summers reach an average of 82°F in July. The area receives 314 sunny days per year, well above the national average of 205. Annual rainfall totals 50.6 inches. Air quality is rated Good with a median Air Quality Index (AQI) of 41.
How is the job market in Butler Beach?
Butler Beach has a healthy job market with an unemployment rate of 4.1%, near the national average of 3.6%. The average weekly wage is $1,154. There are 11,005 business establishments in the area, including 771 restaurants and food service locations. The average commute time is 29 minutes, and 25.7% of workers work from home.
How much does housing cost in Butler Beach?
The median home value in Butler Beach is $469,100. Zillow estimates the typical home value at $272,175. For renters, the median monthly rent is $1,682. Fair market rent is $1,296 for a 1-bedroom and $1,526 for a 2-bedroom apartment. The homeownership rate is 85.4%. The average annual property tax is $8,649.
How are the schools in Butler Beach?
Schools in Butler Beach perform well, with an average test score of 7.1 out of 10 / above the national benchmark. 50.4% of adults in Butler Beach hold a bachelor's degree or higher, above the national average of 33.7%. 96.0% have completed high school. 14.2% hold a graduate or professional degree.
How healthy is Butler Beach?
The obesity rate in Butler Beach is 29.3% (below the national rate of 32.1%). 11.0% of adults are smokers. 16.9% are physically inactive. 20.1% of residents report depression. 9.1% lack health insurance. 91.3% of residents have access to exercise opportunities. The primary care physician ratio is 1:1,052.
What is transportation like in Butler Beach?
The average commute in Butler Beach is 29 minutes. 67.4% of workers drive alone to work, and 25.7% work from home.
What are the demographics of Butler Beach?
The racial and ethnic makeup of Butler Beach is 94.9% White, 0.9% Black or African American, 1.6% Hispanic or Latino. 93.6% of residents speak only English at home, while 6.4% speak Spanish. 8.5% of the population are military veterans. 10.6% of residents have a disability. 94.4% have health insurance coverage.
All Countries
