Monticello, IN

Indiana

Monticello is a small city in Indiana with a population of 5,504. Residents earn $50,138 per year, which is 33% below the national average.

3.5 /5.0
B+ Good
5,504 Population 1,586/sq mi density
$50,138 Median Income $28,381 per capita
$122,200 Home Value $230,935 Zillow
$860 Median Rent
52°F Avg Temperature
B+
Overall
3.5 / 5.0
Good overall score based on economy, affordability, safety and education
B+
Economy
3.6 / 5.0
$50,138 median income, 4.5% unemployment
A+
Affordability
5.0 / 5.0
$122,200 home value, $860/mo rent
D
Education
2.0 / 5.0
11.9% bachelor's degree or higher
Median Income $50,138
33% lower than US avg
Home Value $122,200
57% lower than US avg
Bachelor's+ 11.9%
65% lower than US avg
Median Rent $860
26% lower than US avg
Obesity Rate 47.5%
48% higher than US avg
Unemployment 4.5%
25% higher than US avg
Poverty Rate 4.8%
61% lower than US avg

How Monticello Compares to the U.S. Average (100% = U.S. avg)

People

Population5,504
Median Age46.9 yrs
Density1,586/mi²
Male / Female46% / 54%
Largest GroupWhite 90%

Economy

B+
Median Income$50,138
Per Capita$28,381
Unemployment4.5%
Poverty4.8%
County GDP$1,514M
Commute18 min

Housing

A+
Home Value$122,200
Rent$860
OwnershipN/A
Zillow$230,935

Crime

ViolentN/A
PropertyN/A

Health

Obesity47.5%
UninsuredN/A
Depression27.8%
Heart Disease6.4%

Climate

Avg Temp52°F
AQI41 (Good)
Rain39.0 in/yr
Elevation684 ft

Education

D
Bachelor's+11.9%
High School+93.3%
School Score6.01

Community

2024 VoteR 71% / D 26%
Commute18 min
EV Stations1
Libraries4

Is Monticello a Good Place to Live?

Based on current data, Monticello receives an overall livability score of 3.5 out of 5.0, earning a grade of B+. Key strengths include affordable housing, a low poverty rate. Areas to be aware of include below-average incomes, high obesity rates. Monticello offers a solid quality of life with a good balance of affordability, safety, and opportunity.

Economy & Jobs

The median household income in Monticello is $50,138, 33% below the national average of $75,149. Unemployment stands at 4.5%, indicating a healthy job market. Only 4.8% of residents live below the poverty line, well below the national rate of 12.4%. Workers commute an average of 18 minutes, shorter than most U.S. cities.

Cost of Living & Housing

The median home value in Monticello is $122,200, 57% below the national median — offering relatively affordable homeownership. Renters pay a median of $860 per month, below the national average — a plus for affordability. At just 2.4x median income, home prices are very affordable relative to local earnings.

Education

11.9% of residents hold a bachelor's degree, below the national average of 33.7%. 93.3% have completed high school. Area schools have an average test score of 6/10.

Climate & Weather

Monticello experiences four distinct seasons with an average temperature of 52°F. Winters average 27°F in January while summers reach 74°F in July. Annual precipitation totals 39.0 inches, including 17.2 inches of snow. Air quality is rated Good with a median AQI of 41.

Monticello has a population of 5,504 with a density of 1,586 people per square mile. The median age is 46.9 years, 21% older than the national median of 38.9. The city is predominantly White (90.4%).

Population

5,504
Total Population
1,586
People / sq mi
46.9yrs
Median Age
21% above US avg
3.5mi²
Land Area

Gender Distribution

Male 46.1%
Female 53.9%

Race & Ethnicity

Monticello vs U.S. Average

Language Spoken at Home

English Only92.8%
18% above US avg
Spanish7.2%
46% below US avg

Social Characteristics

Monticello vs U.S. Average

The median household income in Monticello is $50,138, which is 33% below the national average of $75,149. The unemployment rate is 4.5% (above the 3.6% US average). 4.8% of residents live below the poverty line. Workers commute an average of 18 minutes.

Income: Monticello vs U.S.

Commute Mode

Income

Median HH Income$50,138
33% below US avg
Per Capita Income$28,381
Avg Weekly Wage$935
IRS Avg AGI$66,512

Employment & Poverty

Unemployment4.5%
25% above US avg
Poverty Rate4.8%
61% below US avg
Establishments (County)706
County GDP$1,514M

Business (County)

Restaurants52
Healthcare32
Retail99
Manufacturing39

Tax & Cost of Living

Property Tax (IRS)$2,703
23% below US avg
Effective Tax Rate2.21%

Commute & Transportation

Commute Time17.8 min
Work from Home3.6%

Walkability

The median home value in Monticello is $122,200, 57% below the national average. Monthly rent averages $860 (26% below US avg). Zillow estimates the typical home value at $230,935.

Home Value Sources

Ownership Split

Home Values

Census Median$122,200
57% below US avg
Zillow ZHVI$230,935

Real Estate Market (Redfin)

Rental Costs

Census Median Rent$860
26% below US avg

HUD Fair Market Rent

Studio$816
1 Bedroom$882
2 Bedrooms$1,096
3 Bedrooms$1,391
4 Bedrooms$1,590

Ownership & Property

Owner-Occupied61.4%

Property Tax

Avg Tax (IRS)$2,703
23% below US avg
Effective Rate2.21%
In Monticello, 47.5% of adults are obese (above the 32.1% national rate). 27.8% report depression. 29.6% are physically inactive.

Health Metrics: Monticello vs U.S. Average (%)

Chronic Conditions

Obesity47.5%
48% above US avg
Diabetes12.8%
Heart Disease6.4%
High Blood Pressure35.7%
Asthma11.6%
COPD8.7%
Stroke3.4%

Behaviors & Mental Health

Binge Drinking17.2%
Physical Inactivity29.6%
Depression27.8%
Mental Distress20.2%
Physical Distress15.0%

Healthcare Access

Insurance Rate91.4%
Checkup Rate77.9%
Premature Death9,851/100K

Food & Exercise

Food Environment8.7/10
Exercise Access43.9%
Healthcare Facilities32

Crime Rates: Monticello vs U.S. Average (per 100,000)

Violent Crime

Property Crime

Traffic Safety

Fatal Crashes (County/yr)9

Safety Score

Monticello has an average annual temperature of 52°F (11°C). Winters average 27°F in January while summers reach 74°F in July. Annual precipitation is 39.0 inches. Air quality is rated Good with a median AQI of 41.

Temperature

27°F Jan (-3°C) 74°F Jul (23°C)
Annual Average52.2°F
3% below US avg
January Average27°F (-3°C)
July Average74°F (23°C)

Precipitation & Snow

Annual Rainfall39.0 inches
3% above US avg
Snowfall17.2 inches/yr

Air Quality

AQI Median41.0
RatingGood

Geography

Elevation684 ft (208 m)
Area3.5 sq mi (9.0 km²)
Population Density1,586/sq mi
Coordinates40.7452°N, 86.7673°W
County FIPS18181
It is classified as Nonmetro — Urban 2.5K–20K, adjacent. 11.9% of residents hold a bachelor's degree or higher (65% below US avg). In the 2024 election, the county voted Republican by a 45-point margin.

2024 Presidential Election (County)

R 71.4%
D 26.4%

Winner: Republican by 45 points

Education

Bachelor's Degree+11.9%
65% below US avg
High School+93.3%
School Test Score6.01
D Education Grade (2.0/5.0)

Urban-Rural Classification

RUCC Code 6Nonmetro — Urban 2.5K–20K, adjacent
Population Density1,586/sq mi
Total Area3.5 sq mi

Infrastructure & Services

EV Charging Stations1
Alt Fuel Stations2
Public Libraries4
Healthcare Facilities32
Restaurants52
Retail Stores99

Safety & Disasters

Fatal Crashes (County/yr)9

Commute & Transportation

Avg Commute17.8 min
Work from Home3.6%

Nearby Cities

Compare Monticello with another city: